May 29, 20 know your bro with chris and scott evans duration. William frankena and reason in morality philosophers in the western world have from the earliest times subscribed to the idea that morality is possessed of a special reasongiving force. Pdf william frankenas model for analyzing philosophies of. Even though the deductive method in philosophy of education was the subject of attacks, frankenas. Rather christian ethics has stressed obedience to gods will. The tonight show starring jimmy fallon recommended for you. Actionbased theories deontic judgments are primary teleological our duty is to secure the best results hedonism pleasure for me. This book has challenged me about the connection between metaphysics and ethics in that frankena seems to argue that ethics is not r frankena is quite fair in this introduction to normative ethics and meta ethics.
This festschrift seeks to honor three highly distinguished scholars in the department of philosophy, university of michigan. Although he probably will not be considered to be of the same caliber as his younger fellow dutch american. Chapters 2 to 5 will consist chiefly of normative ethics treated along general lines, although some analysis and clarification will come in also. An example of ethical thinking socrates the nature of ethics or. Some argue against virtue ethics by pointing out that a person may possess all the proper virtues and still be unable to tell right from wrong actions. Psychological egoismthe claim that all human beings are so constituted that they always seek their own advantage or. Search for library items search for lists search for contacts search for a library. William frankena says that virtues without principles are blind. He argues that those notions are not related in all the ways hauerwas suggests and that the ties that do link them can be understood on the basis of an. The ethics of love conceived as an ethics of virtue. He had been a professor of philosophy at the university of michigan. Frankena finished his dissertation titled recent intuitionism in british ethics at harvard in 1937 and received his ph.
Morality and moral philosophy o an example of ethical thinking socrates o the nature of ethics or moral philosophy o the nature of morality o factors in morality o kinds of normative judgment o program for rest of book 2. Join researchgate to discover and stay uptodate with the latest. Pdf william frankenas model for analyzing philosophies. William frankena, the highly respected philosopher and insightful critic of christian ethics, once observed that the norm of love has not been foundational in christian ethics. William frankena has suggested a model for analyzing philosophies of education based on practical syllogism which goes back to aristotle. Ethics ethics second edition william k frankena 1973. He was a member of the university of michigans department of philosophy for 41 years 19371978, and chair of the department for 14 years 19471961. Few in the past have dared or even felt the need to challenge such a view, and those who did generally lacked the analytical tools necessary for a clear. The essay originally appeared in frankena s ethics second edition englewood cliffs. Frankena was also known as one of the preeminent historians of ethics of his generation, even though relatively little of his published writing was explicitly devoted to history. However, i came across him again in his introduction to jonathan edwards the nature of true virtue. While he was chair of the michigan philosophy department, frankena devoted a considerable portion of his time to service to the university and the philosophy profession, and became known for his role in. William frankenas model for analyzing philosophies of.
But if you read it, you better supplement it with newer. Sep 09, 2019 frankena the naturalistic fallacy pdf spiritual september 9, 2019 the definist fallacy sometimes socratic fallacy is a logical fallacy, coined by william frankena frankena argued that the naturalistic fallacy is a complete misnomer because it is neither limited to naturalistic properties nor necessarily a. Letter from a birmingham jail martin luther king jr. Each has made significant con tributions to the philosophic literature, particularly in the field of ethics. William frankena in from metaethicsthe history of ethics, and normative ethical theory, to moral education, moral psychology, and applied ethics, to religious ethics and the philosophy of educationthe sweep and quality of.
William klaas frankena june 21, 1908 october 22, 1994 was an american moral philosopher. Arnold and keilh bustos the organization of this essay is as follows. William frankena died on october 22, 1994 in ypsilanti, michigan. The relationship between philosophy and methodology in teaching is to use the best methods, methodology, based on the desired outcomes, philosophy. Actually frankena has four principles of prima facie duty under the principle of beneficence. Traits of character must include the disposition to act and. This relationship is the basis for the frankena model which was designed to help teachers reach proper methodology through philosophy. Letter from a birmingham jail, martin luther king, jr. Buy ethics by william frankena in paperback format at koorong 02904780. Frankena and ethics of virtue william frankena has several times discussed,1 in his usual cautious and judicious manner, a contrast between two types of normative ethics.
On june 23, 1934 he married sadie roelfs and they had two sons, karl and mark. Frankena ethics pdf william klaas frankena june 21, october 22, was an american moral. Analytic philosophers william klaas frankena june 21, 1908 october 22, 1994. Foundations of philosophy series paperback 1973 by william k. Other readers will always be interested in your opinion of the books youve read. William frankena began his higher education at calvin college where he received an a. According to frankena, kants categorical imperativeact only on that maxim which you can at the same time will to be a universal lawis a.
Frankena a critique of virtuebased ethics a virtue is a disposition, quality, habit etc not a principle or rule. Frankena and ethics of virtue william frankena has. This site uses cookies to deliver our services, improve performance, for analytics, and if not signed in for advertising. He was interested in and wrote about almost every question in normative ethics and metaethics see normativity. The former included three historical philosophies of education 1966, and the latter, the ethics of love conceived as an ethics of virtue, which appeared in the journal of religious ethics in 1973. In response to hauerwas, frankena explores the nature of a moral virtue and the relation between virtue and obligation. Frankena distinguishes virtuebased ethical systems from principlebased ones and contends, against virtue ethics, that traits without principles are blind p. With the intent to have a fair basis for judgments or action, one looks to personal ideals of what is appropriate to guide them, rather than an unchanging universal code of conduct, such as biblical law under. This small 98 pages introductory volume to ethics dates back to 1963.
Frankena gives a good overview of a wide array of topics in a clear, simple and compact style. Beneficencebenevolence social philosophy and policy. At the time, i did not know who william frankena was. An example of ethical thinking socrates the nature of ethics or moral philosophy the nature of morality factors in morality kinds of normative judgment program for rest of book egoistic and deontological theories. The exceptions were essays on hutcheson and spinoza, and editions of jonathan edwards on the nature of true virtue 1960 and freedom of the will 1969. Frankena and a great selection of related books, art and collectibles available now at.
It helped to provide introductory framework and arguments for further study. Without claiming that actual philosophers have been pure exemplars of either type, he has tried to give a. Frankena author see all 3 formats and editions hide other formats and editions. Characterbased ethics what is the primary concern of an ethical theory. Situational ethics or situation ethics takes into account the particular context of an act when evaluating it ethically, rather than judging it according to absolute moral standards. Suppose that all your life you have been trying to be a good person, doing your duty as you see it and seeking to do what is for the good of your fellowmen. Even though the deductive method in philosophy of education was the subject of attacks, frankenas model has been influential as it has been appealed to in religious education studies e. Situational ethics is a form of consequentialism though distinct from utilitarianism in that the latters aim is the greatest good for the greatest number that focuses on creating the greatest amount of love. Classic and contemporary readings sixth edition, eds.
Even though the deductive method in philosophy of education was the subject of attacks, frankena s. Full text views reflects the number of pdf downloads, pdfs. Suppose, also, that many of your fellowmen dislike you and what you are doing and even regard. Ethics foundation of philosophy series by william k. During his long career, william frankena has published many articles in theoretical ethics, applied ethics, and the philosophy of education. William frankena critique of virtue based ethics youtube. Personally, frankena embodied to an unusual degree the moral ideals and virtues of character that moral philosophers celebrate. Values and morals essays in honor of william frankena. I read portions of it for a course i took on ethics. The chapter about the nonmoral good is the best one, but the others are good as well. William frankena has several times discussed,1 in his usual cautious and judicious manner, a contrast between two types of normative ethics. Frankena was born on june 21, 1908 in manhattan, montana.
Frankena thinks this isnt even ethics not a genuine moral theory because its point of view is interested or prudential, whereas the moral point of view is disinterested. Whether youve loved the book or not, if you give your honest and detailed thoughts then people will find new books that are right for them. William k frankena normative theories of obligation, moral and nonmoral value, and metaethical issues and theories are considered. Even though the deductive method in philosophy of education was the subject of attacks, frankena s model has been influential as it has been appealed to in religious education studies e. William frankenas analysis of the concept of morality is criticized because of its implications for understanding christian morality. Frankena s own metaethical theory of the justification of ethical judgements the ideal concensus not an actual concensus to frankena. An ethics that focuses on principles or duty is an ethic of doing frankena argues that both are necessary.
328 163 937 1050 441 556 1396 1539 737 340 772 1428 97 1150 10 621 1560 254 1414 1189 784 1035 660 206 477 16 48